In contrast, the mathematics needed to analyze such schemes is what forms the focus in Stochastic Approximation (SA) theory [2, 4]. More generally, SA refers to an iterative scheme that helps find zeroes or optimal points of a function, for which only noisy evaluationsarepossible.

We study the convergence of off-policy TD(0) with linear function approximation when used to approximate the expected discounted reward in a Markov chain. It is well known that the combination of off-policy learning and function approximation can lead to divergence of the algorithm. Existing results for this setting modify the algorithm, for instance by reweighing the updates using importance sampling. This establishes convergence at the expense of additional complexity. In contrast, our approach is to analyse the standard algorithm, but to restrict our attention to the class of reversible Markov chains. We demonstrate convergence under this mild reversibility condition on the structure of the chain, which in many applications can be assumed using domain knowledge. In particular, we establish a convergence guarantee under an upper bound on the discount factor in terms of the difference between the on-policy and off-policy process. This improves upon known results in the literature that state that convergence holds for a sufficiently small discount factor by establishing an explicit bound. Convergence is with probability one and achieves projected Bellman error equal to zero. To obtain these results, we adapt the stochastic approximation framework that was used by Tsitsiklis and Van Roy [1997 for the on-policy case, to the off-policy case. We illustrate our results using different types of reversible Markov chains, such as one-dimensional random walks and random walks on a weighted graph.

We thank all the reviewers for their careful feedback and will revise our paper accordingly. Such a fact is presented in the classic paper "An analysis of temporal-difference learning with function Similar facts can be found for other TD algorithms (e.g. Reviewer 1 is correct in that a discount factor is needed. Now we address specific reviewer comments below. A reference for this is the classic paper "An Finally, the "-" sign in Line 213 is due to the Hurwtiz assumption.

A computational problem in biological reward-based learning is how credit assignment is performed in the nucleus accumbens (NAc). Much research suggests that NAc dopamine encodes temporal-difference (TD) errors for learning value predictions. However, dopamine is synchronously distributed in regionally homogeneous concentrations, which does not support explicit credit assignment (like used by backpropagation). It is unclear whether distributed errors alone are sufficient for synapses to make coordinated updates to learn complex, nonlinear reward-based learning tasks. We design a new deep Q-learning algorithm, Artificial Dopamine, to computationally demonstrate that synchronously distributed, per-layer TD errors may be sufficient to learn surprisingly complex RL tasks.

Robot control using reinforcement learning has become popular, but its learning process generally terminates halfway through an episode for safety and time-saving reasons. This study addresses the problem of the most popular exception handling that temporal-difference (TD) learning performs at such termination. That is, by forcibly assuming zero value after termination, unintentionally implicit underestimation or overestimation occurs, depending on the reward design in the normal states. When the episode is terminated due to task failure, the failure may be highly valued with the unintentional overestimation, and the wrong policy may be acquired. Although this problem can be avoided by paying attention to the reward design, it is essential in practical use of TD learning to review the exception handling at termination. This paper therefore proposes a method to intentionally underestimate the value after termination to avoid learning failures due to the unintentional overestimation. In addition, the degree of underestimation is adjusted according to the degree of stationarity at termination, thereby preventing excessive exploration due to the intentional underestimation. Simulations and real robot experiments showed that the proposed method can stably obtain the optimal policies for various tasks and reward designs. https://youtu.be/AxXr8uFOe7M

In this paper we propose novel distributed gradient-based temporal difference algorithms for multi-agent off-policy learning of linear approximation of the value function in Markov decision processes. The algorithms are composed of: 1) local parameter updates based on the single-agent off-policy gradient temporal difference learning algorithms, including eligibility traces with state dependent parameters, and 2) linear dynamic consensus scheme over the underlying, typically sparsely connected, inter-agent communication network. The proposed algorithms differ in the way of how the time-scales are selected, how local recursions are performed and how consensus iterations are incorporated. The algorithms are completely decentralized, allowing applications in which all the agents may have completely different behavior policies while evaluating a single target policy. In this sense, the algorithms may be considered as a tool for either parallelization or multi-agent collaborative learning under given constraints. We provide weak convergence results, taking rigorously into account properties of the underlying Feller-Markov processes. We prove that, under nonrestrictive assumptions on the time-varying network topology and the individual state-visiting distributions of the agents, the parameter estimates of the algorithms weakly converge to a consensus point. The variance reduction effect of the proposed algorithms is demonstrated by analyzing a limiting stochastic differential equation. Specific guidelines for network design, providing the desired convergence points, are given. The algorithms' properties are illustrated by characteristic simulation results.

Learning the value function of a given policy (target policy) from the data samples obtained from a different policy (behavior policy) is an important problem in Reinforcement Learning (RL). This problem is studied under the setting of off-policy prediction. Temporal Difference (TD) learning algorithms are a popular class of algorithms for solving the prediction problem. TD algorithms with linear function approximation are shown to be convergent when the samples are generated from the target policy (known as on-policy prediction). However, it has been well established in the literature that off-policy TD algorithms under linear function approximation diverge. In this work, we propose a convergent on-line off-policy TD algorithm under linear function approximation. The main idea is to penalize the updates of the algorithm in a way as to ensure convergence of the iterates. We provide a convergence analysis of our algorithm. Through numerical evaluations, we further demonstrate the effectiveness of our algorithm.

Emphatic Temporal Difference (ETD) learning has recently been proposed as a convergent off-policy learning method. ETD was proposed mainly to address convergence issues of conventional Temporal Difference (TD) learning under off-policy training but it is different from conventional TD learning even under on-policy training. A simple counterexample provided back in 2017 pointed to a potential class of problems where ETD converges but TD diverges. In this paper, we empirically show that ETD converges on a few other well-known on-policy experiments whereas TD either diverges or performs poorly. We also show that ETD outperforms TD on the mountain car prediction problem. Our results, together with a similar pattern observed under off-policy training in prior works, suggest that ETD might be a good substitute over conventional TD.

The existing methods for image captioning usually train the language model under the cross entropy loss, which results in the exposure bias and inconsistency of evaluation metric. Recent research has shown these two issues can be well addressed by policy gradient method in reinforcement learning domain attributable to its unique capability of directly optimizing the discrete and non-differentiable evaluation metric. In this paper, we utilize reinforcement learning method to train the image captioning model. Specifically, we train our image captioning model to maximize the overall reward of the sentences by adopting the temporal-difference (TD) learning method, which takes the correlation between temporally successive actions into account. In this way, we assign different values to different words in one sampled sentence by a discounted coefficient when back-propagating the gradient with the REINFORCE algorithm, enabling the correlation between actions to be learned. Besides, instead of estimating a "baseline" to normalize the rewards with another network, we utilize the reward of another Monte-Carlo sample as the "baseline" to avoid high variance. We show that our proposed method can improve the quality of generated captions and outperforms the state-of-the-art methods on the benchmark dataset MS COCO in terms of seven evaluation metrics.